Justice Department Antitrust Division Will Review Google’s Fitbit Acquisition
Rumors began to percolate a few weeks back that Fitbit was interested in being acquired. Google was cited as an interested party, and the deal was official just a few days later. The $2.1 billion deal is now facing a new challenge as the US Justice Department has begun a review of the deal on antitrust grounds.
Business deals of this size need approval by either the DOJ or the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), but the agencies allegedly spent a few weeks arguing over which one would tackle the Google-Fitbit issue. The DOJ already has an ongoing antitrust probe of Google, so it makes sense it would lead the way here. The agency’s Antitrust Division will evaluate the impact of this deal to ensure it’s not anti-competitive.
Privacy advocates expressed misgivings about the deal as soon as it was announced. Fitbit holds health-related data from millions of people, and Google is a company built on monetizing data. That has made some people understandably squeamish about the combination of the two, and that’s essentially what the DOJ is investigating — should Google have all this data? Companies have routinely assured regulators that they could keep data private after acquisitions go through, but this unenforceable.
Google’s wearable platform has stagnated for years at this point, and Fitbit might have the technology to make it viable. However, this is a risky time for Google to buy a company that has so much health data. The company is under intense scrutiny at the state and federal level as part of a larger probe of anticompetitive practices in big tech.
Google has a good chance of approval if it can convince regulators that its data protections are sound. There’s no danger of Google gaining a monopoly in the wearable market. Apple is solidly in first place, and Fitbit is a distant third behind Samsung. The DOJ will likely issue a decision in early 2020.
Continue reading
Apple’s M1 iPad Pros Make It Even Harder to Justify an Android Tablet
The previous iPad's A-series ARM chip already outclassed Android tablets, but now Apple's tablets could be in a completely different category.
Intelligence Officials Warn Against Buying Huawei and ZTE Phones, Without Justification
Multiple national security figures in the US have issued a direct warning that consumers should avoid devices from Chinese tech giants Huawei and ZTE. However, the warning lacks any specific claims of wrongdoing.
Sonos Tries and Fails to Justify ‘Recycle Mode’ That Bricks Speakers
The company has come under fire for the wasteful way it encourages customers to upgrade to new speakers — it bricks the old ones. Sonos' defense of this practice is also laughably inept.