Planet Nine Hypothesis Takes a Major Hit in New Study

Planet Nine Hypothesis Takes a Major Hit in New Study

It used to be easy to know how many planets there were: nine. It had been nine planets for an entire generation before scientists started rethinking what counts as a planet. Pluto is out, but some astronomers believe there’s a real ninth planet lurking out there. Others aren’t convinced, and the debate is starting to shift in favor of the planet nine skeptics.

To be clear, there have been crackpots who, at various times, have claimed that a tenth (or ninth) planet was going to collide with Earth. The scientific debate over Planet Nine focuses on a 2016 study penned by astronomers Michael Brown and Konstantin Batygin. In it, the pair shows how the unusual orbits of numerous extreme trans-Neptunian objects (ETNO) could be the result of a massive, undiscovered object in the outer solar system.

Other scientists were understandably skeptical of these claims, but the evidence presented by Brown and Batygin wasn’t as easy to dismiss as conspiracy theories about Planet X. The orbits cited in the study are odd, and they do support the idea there’s a massive something out there. We don’t know it’s a planet, though, and the math suggests it should be substantially larger than Earth. So where is it?! Some scientists have speculated that Planet Nine may actually be a small black hole — after all, the only evidence we have for Planet Nine is gravity.

A new pre-print study led by the University of Michigan’s Kevin Napier posits an alternative explanation. Perhaps, the team says, the supposed clustering of ETNO orbits in the outer solar system is an illusion caused by biased data. According to Napier, it’s very hard to spot the tiny ETNOs at such great distances. So, astronomers have to adjust their telescopes to focus on specific parts of the sky, taking note of both the time of day and year. The result is allegedly an incomplete view of ETNOs. So, the clustering isn’t really clustering — those are just the objects Brown and Batygin happened to catalog.

Planet Nine Hypothesis Takes a Major Hit in New Study

The team went a step further by checking in on 14 ETNOs that were not included in the initial Planet Nine paper. They found no indication these objects were being affected by the supposed Planet Nine.

This study still needs to be peer-reviewed, but the team seems confident. Some of them are even out there talking smack on Twitter. Time will tell who’s right about this, but the Planet Nine supporters are going to need some new evidence to keep up the fight.

Continue reading

AMD Roadmap Leak: Major Platform, Graphics Changes Coming in Zen 4
AMD Roadmap Leak: Major Platform, Graphics Changes Coming in Zen 4

Fresh rumors regarding AMD's long-term product roadmap have arisen and they imply some major improvements and changes coming with Zen 4.

Android 12 Could Include Major App Compatibility Improvements
Android 12 Could Include Major App Compatibility Improvements

Google has attempted to centralize chunks of Android over the years, and a major component called ART is set to get this treatment in Android 12. The result could be vastly improved app compatibility, which is sure to make everyone happy.

NASA’s SLS Rocket Fails Major Engine Test
NASA’s SLS Rocket Fails Major Engine Test

NASA doesn't want to call it a failure, but plenty of others are.

A File Sharing App With 1 Billion Downloads Has a Major Security Flaw
A File Sharing App With 1 Billion Downloads Has a Major Security Flaw

Trend Micro says SHAREit is a security nightmare that could allow intruders to sneak a peek at your data or even install malware. Perhaps most troublingly, the developers have not responded to Trend Micro's warnings.