The UK has announced it will intervene in the proposed acquisition of ARM by Nvidia, citing national security concerns around the transaction. Britain’s Digital Secretary, Oliver Dowden, issued the notice of intervention in the $40B sale, which was announced in the fall of 2020.
The UK announcement isn’t big on details. It states that the “Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport is able to intervene on national security grounds,” and that “This responsibility is discharged in a quasi-judicial capacity.” Dowden is said to have reached the decision to intervene based on “advice received from officials across the investment security community.”
A Matter of National Security?
The announcement of an investigation on the basis of national security should not be read to mean that Britain thinks Nvidia is somehow leaking state secrets to mainland China, Russia, or another geopolitical adversary. Concerns about the way this acquisition could impact the global balance of power in the semiconductor market exist, but Nvidia is not under that type of scrutiny.
ARM doesn’t directly manufacture CPUs. Instead, it develops licenses for both its underlying ISA and discrete, specific, physical cores. You can sign an ARM license allowing you to build a compatible CPU of your choosing, or you can license a specific and particular CPU design, pair it with some other I/O and SoC blocks, and create a “custom” chip for yourself built using off-the-shelf IP at a major foundry. In the past ARM was an independent company, but it’s currently owned by Softbank, which wishes to sell its stake.
ARM has never been owned by a company that was also a licensee of its hardware. If Nvidia is allowed to buy ARM, the design firm whose chips power virtually the entire mobile market would be owned by one of the companies that license its designs. There are fears that Nvidia could exploit its own ownership of ARM to give itself a critical advantage in the market. Regulators in the EU have expressed concerns over this arrangement, and while the UK is no longer part of the EU, it clearly has its own fears on this topic as well.
Opinions on whether the deal will go through are easy to find, and different authors identify different pain points, both with the EU and with China, which has its own reasons not to allow the merger. So long as ARM is primarily affiliated with British companies, China can try to argue that its use of ARM IP shouldn’t be affected by ongoing sanctions levied by the US. If ARM becomes an American company, that argument goes out the window.
The UK has previously indicated it would investigate the proposed merger, so today’s announcement isn’t a surprise. A number of companies that compete with Nvidia in various markets all spoke out against the merger alleging various antitrust concerns. Nvidia has addressed some of the concerns, by guaranteeing that jobs and development centers would remain in Cambridge, for example, and pledging to build a new AI-focused computing center. Other concerns, like China’s ongoing access to ARM IP and how that might change if Nvidia buys ARM from Softbank, are beyond the GPU manufacturer’s control.
Rumors abound that more companies may explore the RISC-V option if Nvidia is allowed to buy ARM, so we might see increased interest in that ISA depending on how all this plays out. The CPU market has become startlingly dynamic for a field largely viewed as moribund just a few years ago. The UK intervention requires an investigation into whether the Nvidia-ARM deal is indeed a threat to the United Kingdom’s national security, with the report due by July 31, 2021.
Nvidia GeForce RTX 3060 Ti Launches Dec. 2, but Good Luck Getting One
The RTX 3060 Ti goes on sale tomorrow for a mere $399—it might even be affordable after the obscene reseller markup!
The US Air Force Quietly Admits the F-35 Is a Failure
The Air Force has finally admitted that the F-35 is not the aircraft the military hoped it would be, though we doubt Ferrari would appreciate being compared with the F-35.
Star Citizen Devs Angry, Forced to Work Through Life-Threatening Texas Storm
Multiple Cloud Imperium Games employees have spoken out against their employer over how they were treated during the 2021 Texas snowstorm.
Nvidia Doubles GeForce Now Subscription Price to $10 Per Month
Nvidia is increasing the paid tier from $5 per month to $10. This brings it more in-line with other streaming platforms, but the price was Nvidia's big advantage until now.