Family Safety App Life360 Caught Selling User Location Data

Family Safety App Life360 Caught Selling User Location Data

Two former Life360 employees, as well as two former employees at location data brokers X-Mode and Cuebiq, recently disclosed to The Markup that Life360 has served as a conduit for massive amounts of raw location data—perhaps the most of any source in the industry. An engineer from X-Mode, one of the brokers to whom Life360 sells location data, said the precision and sheer volume of Life360’s offering made it some of the firm’s most valuable data. Former employees at Life360 also confirmed the company sells user location data to Cuebiq, Arity (owned by Allstate), and Safegraph.

Life360 founder and CEO Chris Hulls refused to confirm or deny to The Markup that his company really serves as the largest source of location data in the industry. What Hulls did say was, “We see data as an important part of our business model that allows us to keep the core Life360 services free for the majority of our users,” which makes sense in a disappointing way; Vizio, too, makes far more money from selling user data than it does from selling its actual product.

Family Safety App Life360 Caught Selling User Location Data

Those who use (or now, formerly used) Life360 are probably wondering what happens to their data after it’s sold. X-Mode, Cuebiq, and SafeGraph largely focus on extracting insights from mass amounts of location data and then selling those insights to other companies for advertising and other purposes. Cuebiq began working with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to track mobility trends at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, but has publicly stated it refuses to work directly with law enforcement agencies and it also won’t provide raw data to government agencies. This contrasts starkly with X-Mode and SafeGraph, whose software development kits were banned by Google for selling user data to the government, including the US military.

Last year Life360 began prohibiting the sale of its data to law enforcement, citing a philosophical conflict with [bypassing] an individual’s right to due process. While Life360 isn’t selling its users’ location information directly to law enforcement agencies, however, its newly-revealed customers might very well be. A small disclaimer at the bottom of the Life360 app tells new users that their data may be used “for the purposes of crash detection, research, analytics, attribution and tailored advertising,” but it does not say anything about giving investors a leg up in the stock market or telling the military your last several locations.

Continue reading

OnePlus Caught Manipulating Smartphone Performance Benchmarks
OnePlus Caught Manipulating Smartphone Performance Benchmarks

Despite having ample power, the OnePlus 9 is aggressively throttling performance for most apps while allowing benchmarks full power. As a result, its phones have been pulled from the Geekbench charts.

Western Digital Caught Bait-and-Switching Customers With Slow SSDs
Western Digital Caught Bait-and-Switching Customers With Slow SSDs

Western Digital is the latest company caught bait-and-switching its customers with lousy SSD speeds. In other news, Samsung and Intel don't appear to be trying to cheat customers this way, while Crucial and Adata apparently are.

Samsung Is the Latest SSD Manufacturer Caught Cheating Its Customers
Samsung Is the Latest SSD Manufacturer Caught Cheating Its Customers

Samsung has joined the ranks of companies found shipping faster SSDs to reviewers than to consumers without telling anyone about it.

Samsung Caught Cheating Customers Again, But On TVs This Time
Samsung Caught Cheating Customers Again, But On TVs This Time

Samsung has been caught cheating again, but this time it's on TVs, not SSDs or smartphones.