Microsoft Alleges Sony Pays Developers to Keep Games Off Game Pass

Microsoft Alleges Sony Pays Developers to Keep Games Off Game Pass

Microsoft’s bid for Activision is undergoing regulatory scrutiny in several countries, Brazil included. Last month, Brazil’s Administrative Council for Economic Defense (CADE) prompted companies that would potentially be affected by the merger to provide their input. While Google, Apple, and other major tech companies appeared relatively neutral, Sony took the opportunity to say Microsoft’s acquisition of Call of Duty—Activision’s most popular and lucrative franchise—could “influence users’ console choice,” thus skewing the video games market.

Microsoft appears to have found incongruity in Sony’s comment. The company sent a 27-page document to CADE addressing Sony’s claim; VGC transcribed the document (originally written in Spanish) late last week.

“Considering that exclusivity strategies have been at the core of Sony’s strategy to strengthen its presence in the games industry, and that Sony is a leader in the distribution of digital games, Sony’s concern with possible exclusivity of Activision‘s content is incoherent, to say the least,” Microsoft said. “Indeed, Microsoft’s ability to continue expanding Game Pass has been obstructed by Sony’s desire to inhibit such growth. Sony pays for ‘blocking rights’ to prevent developers from adding content to Game Pass and other competing subscription services.”

Microsoft Alleges Sony Pays Developers to Keep Games Off Game Pass

Microsoft’s assertion that Sony pays developers to keep their games away from Game Pass is a bold one, but it appears to be well-founded. A screenshot of court documents from last year’s Epic Games vs. Apple lawsuit reveals that Sony pays developers to keep their games exclusive to PlayStation subscription services for variable periods of time. During the negotiated period, developers are explicitly prohibited from including their games on “competitive platforms,” including Microsoft’s Game Pass and Google’s Stadia Pro.

From Microsoft’s perspective, it’s hypocritical for Sony to criticize one company’s hypothetical removal of a franchise from a particular company’s consoles while essentially doing the same behind (mostly) closed doors. Microsoft didn’t hold itself back from expressing this, either. “Sony rails against the introduction of new monetization models capable of challenging its business model,” the company wrote in its response to CADE.

Given the ongoing nature of Microsoft’s back-and-forth with CADE, it’s unknown where Brazil’s regulatory watchdog stands on the Activision acquisition. It’s far from alone, though; verdicts in the US, UK, Australia, Japan, and other regions are still outstanding.

Continue reading

Intel Sues Former Employee For Alleged Theft of Xeon Data
Intel Sues Former Employee For Alleged Theft of Xeon Data

Intel has alleged trade secret theft by a former employee.

Another Tesla Allegedly Collides With Emergency Vehicle in Autopilot Mode
Another Tesla Allegedly Collides With Emergency Vehicle in Autopilot Mode

An investigation is underway, but this doesn't look great as Tesla faces questions from government regulators about this very issue.

Crucial Responds to Bait-and-Switch Allegations and the P2 SSD
Crucial Responds to Bait-and-Switch Allegations and the P2 SSD

We sat down with Crucial to discuss the P2 SSD, how it configures its storage products, and the current level of performance variation in the SSD market.

AMD Allegedly Jacking Up RX 6000 GPU Prices by 10 Percent
AMD Allegedly Jacking Up RX 6000 GPU Prices by 10 Percent

TSMC wafer costs are reportedly causing AMD to up the price it charges its board partners for RX 6000 series GPUs.