Judge: Police Can’t Force You to Unlock Phone With Fingerprint or Face ID

Every smartphone of note these days has some sort of biometric unlock option, be that fingerprint, iris scanning, or face unlock. US courts have held that your right against self-incrimination does not extend to these biometric features, making them less secure than a password. However, a federal judge just said quite the opposite in a ruling. The District Court for the Northern District of California says that police can’t force you to unlock a phone with your face or fingerprints.

This is a complicated situation, but it all traces back to the Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution. That’s the one that forbids the government from forcing someone to give evidence against themselves. When you hear about someone “taking the fifth,” they’re refusing to answer a question on the grounds that it may incriminate them. The Fifth Amendment also means you don’t have to talk to the police — the rights police enumerate when arresting someone include “you have the right to remain silent.”

Courts have previously held that police can’t force a suspect to provide a password to unlock an electronic device. That counts as “testimonial” information and is protected by the Constitution. A body part is a different matter. Can a physical feature be protected under the Fifth Amendment? Most judges have said no, and police have used this rationale to unlock phones with the suspect’s fingerprints and more recently their face. That’s been a boon to investigators in this era when most phones are encrypted out of the box.

Now, judge Kandis Westmore has disagreed with that legal reasoning. The California case revolved around an attempted extortion scam in which a suspect demanded money to prevent the release of “embarrassing” videos. Police requested a search warrant that allowed them to unlock any smartphone found at the location using a fingerprint, face, or iris scan.

The judge, in this case, denied the warrant on two grounds. First, the request to search all phones at the location was overly broad. More significantly, Westmore equated biometric features to a password. “If a person cannot be compelled to provide a passcode because it is a testimonial communication, a person cannot be compelled to provide one’s finger, thumb, iris, face, or other biometric feature to unlock that same device,” the judge wrote. In short, forcing someone to use their body to unlock a phone counts as self-incrimination under the Fifth Amendment.

Higher courts could easily disagree with this ruling, and the law is still very much unclear. Police will probably continue to use biometric features to unlock devices until someone mounts a major challenge to the practice that could take years to wind its way through the courts. In the meantime, a password is still the best way to protect your data.

Continue reading

Sony Will Unlock the PS5’s Expandable Storage by This Summer

The PlayStation 5 will finally be able to boost its internal capacity this summer, with M.2 drive support arriving along with new fan profile updates.

Alder Lake Extravaganza: Intel Unloads Details on its Next-Gen CPU

Intel's desktop CPUs have been stuck on 14nm for over six years now, and the cracks in that process node have been showing for at least two. The manufacturer was finally ready to share details on Alder Lake, Gracemont, and Golden Cove with us, and it had a lot to talk about.

Samsung Breaks the Galaxy Z Fold3’s Cameras If You Unlock the Bootloader

Unlocking allows you to root a phone and make changes to the core software. Naturally, most device makers discourage this behavior, but Samsung's setup on the Fold3 is downright hostile to modders.

Oculus Gives Discontinued Oculus Go a New Lease on Life with Unlocked Software

The release of the Oculus Go in 2018 was an important step for Facebook's Virtual Reality division, but the product was short-lived. After being made obsolete by the Oculus Quest, the company discontinued the Go in 2020. Still, Facebook sold millions of the standalone headsets, and now they're more capable thanks to an unlocked software update.