Skydio Gets Wrong Kind of Press for Showcasing ‘Illegal’ Drone Video

Despite having raised over $70 million and launching a unique and interesting drone, Skydio hasn’t been that well known. Until now. The company apparently showcased a “follow-me” video of a rollerblader on the boardwalk at West Thumb Geyser Basin in Yellowstone National Park. Drones are not actually illegal in every National Park; I’ve flown one in Red Rock Canyon National Park, where it is allowed except in the Wilderness Area and if you don’t disturb people or animals. But drones are most definitely illegal in Yellowstone. In fact, it was a drone crashing into the fragile Grand Prismatic Spring in 2015 that helped solidify the National Park Service’s position on drones in most parks.

The video in question was tagged as being from Iceland, not Wyoming, and simply titled “Thermal tour a la rollerblade,” according to DPReview. Once readers noticed the discrepancy and brought it to Skydio’s attention, the video was taken down. Exclusive to wfoojjaec, we’ve spoken with company executives who say that they had no idea that the video was taken in a National Park, are sorry that it happened, and sorry that they posted the footage to their Instagram account. They have instituted changes in their policies so that it doesn’t happen again.

Here is CEO Adam Bry’s statement to wfoojjaec on what happened:

We’re sorry that one of our drones was flown in a national park and further that we posted the footage on our Instagram account. When we got the footage from the influencer using the drone, we didn’t realize it had been taken in Yellowstone. As soon as we found out, we took the post down. Skydio is made up of people who love the outdoors and we want to encourage people to use our products responsibly. We fell short on that in this instance, and have instituted changes in how we work with influencers and how we screen incoming footage to avoid situations like this in the future.

As far as the video itself, the park is investigating, but no conclusions have been reached yet. Fines of about $1,000 per pilot have been levied against many of the 40 drone operators reported to Yellowstone National Park rangers.

To be clear, as the Grand Prismatic incident demonstrates, the issue isn’t just about annoying buzzing from flying things ticking off visitors. Many natural habitats, including Grand Prismatic and many other Yellowstone highlights, are not areas you can simply walk or wade into in order to retrieve an errant drone. The simple act of trying to retrieve a drone could seriously damage the site, and leaving a bundle of plastic, metal, batteries, and electronics there can also cause trouble. Perhaps in earlier times, like 2014, before this was all made abundantly clear, ignorance might have been an excuse. Now, there is no excuse. Taking Skydio at their word, it appears that they didn’t actively participate in this travesty and were fooled into believing they’d received footage from Iceland, but someone clearly flew the drone in blatant disregard for the ecosystem of the park.

How Do the Parks Control Airspace?

The short answer is that they don’t. Parks can’t issue a blanket ban on UAVs flying anywhere over the park. They can ban launching, landing, or operating a drone from within the park, and also enforce their existing provisions against disturbing wildlife or other visitors. Since the Skydio drone has quite a short range and is designed to actively follow a person or vehicle, there really isn’t any way footage like that described could have been taken legally.

Skydio Is Cool, but the R1 Is a One-Trick Pony

The Skydio R1 drone has by far the best active tracking and avoidance system of any consumer drone. The system includes an Nvidia TX1 at its core, along with a dozen tracking cameras. It’s possible to fly it in and around trees with confidence, something I have never felt comfortable doing with any of the Mavic drones — although the Mavic 2 is getting pretty good as long as you’re careful. However, it doesn’t have much range or battery life, doesn’t support a physical controller, and doesn’t have third-party application support. So for $1,499 (the new, reduced price) you’re spending a lot to make follow-me videos. Our colleague Jim Fisher at PCMag gave it a Fair rating in his full review.

Top image credit: [David Cardinal]

Continue reading

How to Be a Task Manager Wizard, According to the Guy Who Wrote It

The author of the original Windows Task Manager has some tips on how to use it more effectively, including a few we'd never heard of — and one we tossed in ourselves if you have trouble with Task Manager getting stuck behind fullscreen-stealing windows.

RISC vs. CISC Is the Wrong Lens for Comparing Modern x86, ARM CPUs

Try to investigate the differences between the x86 and ARM processor families (or x86 and the Apple M1), and you'll see the acronyms CISC and RISC. It's a common way to frame the discussion, but not a very useful one. Today, "RISC versus CISC" obscures more than it explains.

I Wrote the First Full Review of the Voodoo 5 6000. 3dfx Isn’t Coming Back [Updated]

Nearly 20 years ago, I wrote the first review of the Voodoo 5 6000. As much as I loved 3dfx, I don't think this is the company to resurrect it.

GPU Pricing, Availability Are Moving in the Wrong Direction

GPU prices are moving again, but not in the direction we'd prefer.