HBM2 vs. GDDR6: New Video Compares, Contrasts Memory Types

HBM2 vs. GDDR6: New Video Compares, Contrasts Memory Types

As we’ve talked about various aspects of GPU and memory technology, one point that readers have raised are how HBM2 and GDDR6 compare against each other, and which one is really seen as the better option for various types of applications.

A new video by SemiconductorEngineering dives into the topic, with a comparison by Steven Woo, a Rambus fellow.

One point Woo makes is that the differences between HBM2 and GDDR6 are less about raw capability and more about what kind of design tradeoffs the engineering team wants to make. With GDDR5 versus HBM, there was a clear and absolute bandwidth advantage that HBM could offer. This is less the case with GDDR6, thanks to that memory’s higher bandwidth capabilities, but there are still use-cases where HBM2 has an advantage.

GDDR6 vs HBM2
GDDR6 vs HBM2

This slide, from 11:44 in the talk, illustrates some of the differences between the two memory types. Data rates on GDDR6 are much higher per-pin, but there are far fewer pins overall. The amount of area dedicated to the PHY (the circuitry required to implement the actual physical connection) and the power costs required. The PHY area is 1.5x – 1.75x larger, while the power cost can be 3.5x – 4.5x higher.

This echoes statements AMD made back when it explained why it used HBM for its Fury X GPUs. AMD’s explanation was that, above certain capacities, the energy and area requirements for GDDR5 made it a substantially worse choice than HBM. Woo’s comments indicate that this remains the case today, with HBM2 still offering better performance/watt and better overall power consumption.

That’s our expectation as well. Navi, at least, is anticipated to be a GDDR6 chip and all of Nvidia’s refreshed Turing cards have relied on the RAM type. It’s generally expected that AMD will also move away from HBM2 once it refreshes its high-end GPUs.

Continue reading

Nvidia Will Mimic AMD’s Smart Access Memory on Ampere: Report
Nvidia Will Mimic AMD’s Smart Access Memory on Ampere: Report

AMD's Smart Access Memory hasn't even shipped yet, but Nvidia claims it can duplicate the feature.

Nvidia Unveils Ampere A100 80GB GPU With 2TB/s of Memory Bandwidth
Nvidia Unveils Ampere A100 80GB GPU With 2TB/s of Memory Bandwidth

Nvidia announced an 80GB Ampere A100 GPU this week, for AI software developers who really need some room to stretch their legs.

AMD Will Bring Smart Access Memory Support to Intel, Nvidia Hardware
AMD Will Bring Smart Access Memory Support to Intel, Nvidia Hardware

AMD is reportedly working with Nvidia and Intel to bring hardware support for Smart Access Memory to other GPU and CPU platforms.

Tesla Ordered to Recall 150K+ Vehicles to Repair Memory Failures
Tesla Ordered to Recall 150K+ Vehicles to Repair Memory Failures

Tesla has been asked — or "asked" — to recall some 159,000 vehicles to repair a NAND memory issue that will eventually cause failures on every affected vehicle.