Scientists Testify in Holmes Trial: Theranos Tech Was Downright Bad

Scientists Testify in Holmes Trial: Theranos Tech Was Downright Bad

Just a few short years ago, biomed startup Theranos was a media darling, and founder Elizabeth Holmes was being lauded as a self-made billionaire. All it took to topple Theranos was an article from John Carreyrou asking some tough questions about the company’s Edison blood testing machine. With the company now shuttered, former CEO Holmes is facing charges for defrauding investors. According to laboratory managers called to testify, Holmes should have known Edison was a dud, Ars Technica reports.

Holmes dropped out of college in 2003 at age 19 to start Theranos. The goal of the company’s secretive Edison technology was to conduct assays on smaller samples of blood, what you’d get from a finger stick as opposed to a syringe. Traditionally, scientists and engineers believed this was impossible because finger sticks are much “messier” samples with cellular debris and skin mixed in with the blood. Still, Theranos claimed Edison could do it. Naturally, a lot of companies were interested.

Theranos eventually contracted with numerous pharmaceutical firms to develop tests for Edison (below), something that Holmes has leaned on repeatedly in her defense. Holmes told investors that Edison had been “comprehensively validated” by multiple big pharma outfits. That meant Edison worked, and therefore she was not guilty of fraud. The problem, however, is that the laboratory managers who tested Edison are still around and willing to give testimony.

Scientists Testify in Holmes Trial: Theranos Tech Was Downright Bad

Prosecutors had Victoria Sung from Celgene on the stand and asked point-blank if Edison was “comprehensively validated.” Sung was clear that, no, the machines were not validated. In her testing, Edison machines failed to produce valid results over 14 percent of the time, far higher than the 2 percent rate of the industry-standard QPS test that uses more blood. That put it far outside the realm of clinical usability, so Celgene backed out of the deal.

Also in court on Thursday was former Theranos lab manager Dr. Adam Rosendorff, who confirmed that he signed off on results that he did not believe were accurate. He claims he did this under pressure from Holmes and COO Sunny Balwani, who was also Holmes’ squeeze at the time. Rosendorff also explained how Holmes and Balwani had ordered workers in the Edison lab to remain inside with the door closed when government inspectors came calling. That implies Holmes knew about the issues with Edison while she was telling investors that it worked like a charm.

The testimony is not shaping up well for Holmes so far, and prosecutors have much more to present.

Continue reading

Scientists Haven’t ‘Created’ a Warp Bubble, But They’re a Bit Closer to Testing One
Scientists Haven’t ‘Created’ a Warp Bubble, But They’re a Bit Closer to Testing One

Sorry, hopeful Trekkies, but we have to burst everyone's warp bubble. Despite recent reports that scientists had built a real warp bubble, it looks like warp speed is still a few baby steps away. But all hope is not lost: we sat down with Dr. Harold G. "Sunny" White, whose research team has recently proposed a structure that could be built in the real world to study the Casimir effect.

Amazon’s Satellite Internet Antenna Pulls 400Mbps During Testing
Amazon’s Satellite Internet Antenna Pulls 400Mbps During Testing

Amazon's upcoming Project Kuiper service will be similar to Starlink, but the company claims its prototype Ka phased-array antenna will give it the edge.

Microsoft Now Testing Dual-Screen Gaming in Xbox Game Pass on Surface Duo
Microsoft Now Testing Dual-Screen Gaming in Xbox Game Pass on Surface Duo

Dual screen support has arrived in the latest Xbox Game Pass beta. Only a handful of devices can use the mode today, but it could meaningfully improve gaming on dual screen hardware.

Microsoft Kicks Unsupported PCs From Windows 11 Testing Program
Microsoft Kicks Unsupported PCs From Windows 11 Testing Program

As the October launch date for Windows 11 grows closer, Microsoft is standing firm on the new software's spec requirements. In fact, anyone running the beta on unacceptable hardware is being booted from the program, and their only option is to accept defeat and reinstall Windows 10.